Chael Sonnen's Harsh Critique of Islam Makhachev

In a recent episode of Good Guy / Bad Guy on ESPN MMA, aired on May 19, 2025, Chael Sonnen delivered a scathing assessment of UFC Lightweight Champion Islam Makhachev's decision to move up to the welterweight division. Starting around the 2:51 mark, Sonnen labeled the move as an 'act of cowardice,' suggesting that Makhachev is avoiding a challenge from an undefeated, top-ranked contender at 155 pounds. Sonnen argued that Makhachev's choice to leave his lightweight belt behind reflects a desire to escape rather than defend his title against formidable opposition in his current weight class.

Sonnen's comments were pointed, emphasizing that abandoning the lightweight title to chase a second belt at welterweight undermines the champion's credibility. He questioned the motivation behind the shift, implying that it prioritizes personal gain over the integrity of defending one's division. This perspective stirred significant discussion during the segment, highlighting tensions within the lightweight landscape.

Debating the End of the Champ-Champ Era

Transitioning to a broader topic at roughly the 10:51 timestamp, Sonnen and co-host Daniel Cormier discussed whether Makhachev's potential title vacancy signals the end of the 'champ-champ' era in the UFC. They explored how the organization might be moving away from fighters holding belts in multiple divisions simultaneously. The conversation pointed to a possible shift in UFC policy or fighter strategy, where maintaining dominance in a single division could take precedence over chasing additional titles.

The hosts debated the implications for fighters who aim to achieve double-champion status, with Sonnen suggesting that the focus might now be on legacy within one weight class. This segment provided insight into the evolving dynamics of UFC title reigns and how Makhachev's decision could influence future contenders' paths.

Will Makhachev Return to Lightweight?

At around the 13:51 mark, the discussion turned to whether Makhachev would ever return to the 155-pound division after moving up. Sonnen expressed skepticism about a potential comeback, citing the challenges of cutting weight again and the allure of new opportunities at welterweight. The segment examined how such a move could reshape Makhachev's career trajectory and affect the lightweight division's competitive balance.

The hosts also considered the impact on fans and the division's rankings, noting that a permanent departure could open doors for other fighters to claim the vacated title. This part of the conversation underscored the uncertainty surrounding Makhachev's future plans and the ripple effects of his choices.

Lightweight Division's New Contenders

Moving forward in the episode at approximately the 16:21 point, attention shifted to the upcoming lightweight title fight between Ilia Topuria and Charles Oliveira during International Fight Week. With Topuria listed as a heavy favorite, Sonnen and Cormier analyzed why Oliveira, often referred to as 'Do Bronx,' might be underestimated despite his proven track record. They highlighted Oliveira's resilience and skill set, suggesting that overlooking him could be a mistake for both fans and oddsmakers.

Further into the discussion at the 20:51 timestamp, the state of the lightweight division was dissected. The hosts evaluated how the potential vacancy of Makhachev's title and the emergence of new matchups could redefine the division's hierarchy. This analysis provided a comprehensive look at the shifting landscape and the fighters poised to capitalize on these changes.

Looking Beyond Lightweight: Middleweight Title Fight

Towards the end of the show, around the 24:01 mark, the focus briefly shifted to a highly anticipated middleweight title fight between Dricus Du Plessis (DDP) and Khamzat Chimaev, set for later in the summer in Chicago. Sonnen and Cormier debated whether this matchup represents the best fight the UFC can currently offer on paper. They praised the stylistic clash and the stakes involved, rounding out the episode with excitement for another division's marquee event.

This segment, while not directly tied to Makhachev's situation, showcased the hosts' ability to pivot across weight classes, offering viewers a broader perspective on the UFC's upcoming slate of fights. The discussion reinforced the notion that significant changes and blockbuster matchups are on the horizon across multiple divisions.